Skip to main content

Made by a Fabricista: Sewing a Men's Button-down Shirt

I'm sure you've heard the phrase, "The way to a man's heart is through his stomach." Well this is very true with my husband. But I also think that making things for someone shows that you really care because you're taking time to do something for someone else. 

My husband needed some new button-down shirts for work, so I decided that I would make some for him. I had three different shirting fabrics and a pattern in my stash, I just needed to sit down and do it! So I made a vow that I was going to start and finish all three of these shirts before I worked on any other project. (Haha, how many of us say that?!) I used McCall #6044 and three different cotton shirtings I bought from Fabric Mart a few years ago.




The first shirt I cut out in size large because that's "what the pattern told me to do." I knew that when I make clothing for myself I never make my ready-to-wear size, so I was expecting the same thing here. When my husband tried the shirt on, I ended up having to take it in a whole size! So I stopped working on that shirt and cut out the next shirt in size medium.

There were just a few changes I made to the pattern. I cut out the collar in size large, because he has a larger neck circumference. On ready-to-wear shirts, he has to leave the button at the top open (when wearing a tie.) I also had to make the sleeves 1 1/4" shorter and the hem 2" shorter.


The pattern was quite simple as far as details go. I added a yoke to the back of the shirt to help make it more like a ready-to-wear shirt. I also added top-stitching to the shoulder seams, and armhole. I had a hard time finding a thread that matched the background color, so I selected a deep navy thread. It matches some of the pin-striping in the fabric.


I used Pellon Shir-Tailor Fusible Interfacing for the collar and cuffs. I used a lighter weight interfacing on the button yoke because the Shir-Tailor made it too stiff. 

Overall, I really enjoyed making these shirts! They were fairly easy and I whipped up two in one weekend. I don't think we're going to be buying button-down shirts anymore. I will be shopping for fabric instead!


We have a nice selection of cotton shirting right now. Here are a few shirting picks I think would be great for a men's shirt. 


         

CGE6316 - Wrinkle-free Shirting - Bright Kiwi/ White  
SNE6317 - Multi-Stripe Cotton Shirting - Bronze/Black/White



What will you be making for your significant other?









Comments

  1. Love the shirting in the modeled shirt! The dotted pinstripes are lovely. And you've now made me feel guilty enough to want to make a muslin up for the man!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Button down normally refers to the collar type which has buttonholes at the tips and buttons on the shirt front just under the neckline that corrals the tie. Did you opt not to put on the buttons and buttonholes? From experience, they can be a real pain in the patoot to get exact. RTW factories have such wonderful specialized machines. But nice job. Sewing for appreciative menfolk can be very gratifying.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I put buttons and buttonholes on the front and the sleeve cuffs-- his tie is just covering them up in the picture. My sewing machine is a life-saver when it comes to buttonholes. I have a Bernina which I am able to program the size of each buttonhole, therefore each buttonhole is the same size.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I make my husband's dress shirts all the time. He has a large chest and arms, but is trim in the middle, so buying shirts to fit his neck/chest and arms always gives him a ton of extra fabric around the waist. Believe it or not, the most difficulty I have is finding cool buttons that match, but don't cost more than the shirting fabric. I now use WAWAK for a lot of my sewing and tailoring supplies. I make dress shirts for my son as well, but he doesn't need as many as my DH.

    I find ties are very economical to make, and simple at that. I yard of fabric will make 2 ties...one for each of the men in my life. Its more difficult to purchase tie fabric on line for me, however, because I like to see the drape and heft of the fabric before I purchase it. I have made ties out of cotton before, and they turned out fine. One just gets a better drape and wear from a silk tie.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It's so nice to see that there are others making shirts for their husbands! I was worried that my husband would be fussy about "handmade" items, but was happy about the response!

    Thank you for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I've made a few shirts for myself. In think the "sewing Men's products" have been totally under-used.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Good fit, I really like this shirt and the color is perfect for my lifestyle i would like to buy this from mens shirts store.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great job! Don't show this to my husband please otherwise he will be putting in his order to me lol. I haven't tried a shirt yet, but I did make him a vest for his birthday a few months ago. Maybe he will get a shirt for Christmas. Great job and nice color combo!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Thanks for leaving a comment! All comments are reviewed before posting to help us eliminate spam. Your comment will be posted within 24 hours.

Popular Posts You Might Like

Made By A Fabricista: Closing 2025 with a Lined Jacket

Hello again, sewing friends! It seems we have arrived yet again in the grandest season for layering, all this oncoming cold weather. I like ending the year with something warm and very useful. Seems based on my past Fabricista posts, I love to sew year-end outerwear, and this round is no different!  I challenged myself with a new lined coat (wait, jacket? Coat? I feel like the presence of wool changes things?). Anyhoo, since the lovely Chalk & Notch Den Jacket has been in my queue, I proceeded ahead. I like the large pockets, the option to line or not, and the extra bodice and sleeve seams for topstitching.  Sewing this coat is not at all difficult, but the many pieces and loads of topstitching will take a bit of time. My version took me a few multiple-hour sessions to complete. I sewed a size 2, which matches my measurements, and I made no alterations. Hint: for a quick size test, just employ the lining pieces.  Gorgeous, muted blue as a soft wool flannel ? This is ...

Made By A Fabricista: Chalk and Notch Wren Dress: My Buffet dress for the Christmas season!

  I recently sewed the Chalk and Notch Wren dress using a beautifully soft black voile from Fabric Mart, and it turned into such a satisfying, enjoyable project. The pattern itself is very easy to understand and straightforward with clear instructions, intuitive construction, and a relaxed fit that makes the sewing process easy. A buffet dress in the sewing community is a dress that is loose fitting, so you can eat at the buffet without your dress being uncomfortable afterwards, lol! Because the voile I chose is extremely thin and transparent, I opted to line the bodice and first tier. Adding a lining not only provided modesty but also gave the delicate fabric a bit more stability, especially around the neckline and button placket. A helpful tip when sewing a lining into a lightweight bodice is to treat the lining and the main fabric as one. I sewed the bodice as you would for a lined bodice, and the first tier I sewed the pieces together with a basting stitch to make the process...

Made By A Fabricista: Sheer Elegance and Everyday Comfort with my Two New Tops

Hello Sewing Friends! It’s Sharon from Sharon Sews with my last Fabricista make for 2025. While many sew a special holiday outfit at year’s end, I went in another direction sewing two tops that couldn’t be more different. One is sheer and elegant while the other is easy comfort for everyday wear.  These tops reflect how I dress at this stage of life. As an over-50 sewist, these two tops reflect how I dress at this point in my life.  Sometimes I want something a bit special, other times more basic. Either way, sewing them in beautiful fabrics, custom fit to my body, makes all the difference in how I feel when I wear them. Even though I’m quite pleased with my two tops, my original plan was to sew a jacket with the tropical print stretch twill and pair it with a top sewn from the soutache mesh knit . Sadly, I wasn’t quick enough to get enough of the stretch twill to make a jacket, so a top it was!  You do know you have to act fast when you see something you love on Fabric ...