Skip to main content

Made by a Fabricista: My Ditsy Daisy Button Up





I wasn't sure if I should have entitled this post "My J. Crew Knock-off" since I drew heavily from the idea of this adorable J. Crew button up in a daisy Liberty of London print.  When I spotted this very similar shirting fabric from Fabric Mart I knew I needed a daisy button up of my own!          
 

Classic button ups are one of my favorite go-to-work items since I can roll the sleeves down if the A/C is frigid indoors and roll them up when I am out in the field.  For the pattern I used McCalls 6436 which is a classic button up with almost every imaginable pattern piece for a traditional button up with the exception of the sleeve placket and back yoke.  That is to say, there is a lot of cutting out of pattern pieces in this process.  The pattern also includes bust darts and back darts which give it a bit more shaping than other button up's I've sewn.  


This is my "I push my sleeves up like a J. Crew model" pose!


I knew I would want to roll up the sleeves of this top and wanted the seam finishes to look decent so I used this method.  This finish encapsulates the raw edges in each respective seam allowance.  I've used this method before and am partial to it.  I know how to do hong kong seams, flat felled, serged and french seams but I just prefer this method- mostly because there is less fiddly cutting away of tiny strips of fabric which clutters my floor and is tedious.  



When making this shirt I wasn't entirely sure what work clothes it would coordinate with so when it was complete I had fun pairing it up with this skirt.  This has been an orphan skirt in my closet for a while so I am glad its finally found its mate!  It also pairs well with a pair of persimmon slacks.  The little centers of each flower have a shade of pink that is somewhere between pink and red.....persimmon!



If you are interested in making your own button up I recommend the sew-along tutorials from Grainline Studio for the Archer button up.  Most of the techniques you need are covered there and can help you when you are trying to decipher the process.    

As far as patterns there are so many button up patterns that it can be hard to choose.  So here are a few suggestions:
Grainline Archer- a looser fitting button up
Butterick 5526- I've made this one previously and had a good outcome
McCall 6124- nice princess seams on this one
Simplicity 1538- I like the contrasting fabric suggestions on this one
Sewaholic Granville- this was a "Best Pattern of the Year" at Pattern Review

 

I draw a measure of satisfaction from making a knock off item with my own two hands.  The creative process of making a garment has almost completely eclipsed the satisfaction I once felt when buying a similar item at a store.  Its this feeling that brings me back to my cutting and sewing tables again and again.


Thanks for reading, and happy sewing!
Elizabeth 
 

Comments

  1. This shirt is super cute and your execution is right on point! Ain't no homemade looking shirts over here!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Michelle, you make me smile! Oh the dreaded homemade shirt, I sure hope I am past that point in my sewing!

      Delete
  2. This shirt is super cute and your execution is right on point! Ain't no homemade looking shirts over here!

    ReplyDelete
  3. The "scrunched" sleeves of the J. Crew model. LOL. :'-) So true.

    You look beautiful, what a great classic shirt to last a long long time!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your sweet words Dina! I just couldn't help myself with the J. Crew sleeves, it always cracks me up!

      Delete
  4. Nice shirt and looks great with your "orphaned" skirt. Looks like it would work for casual and work very well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Linda! Its always great when one project redeems another!

      Delete

Post a Comment

Thanks for leaving a comment! All comments are reviewed before posting to help us eliminate spam. Your comment will be posted within 24 hours.

Recent Posts You Might Like

Sewing With Intention: New Look 6106 and a More Coordinated Wardrobe

Sometimes a sewing project begins with a beautiful piece of fabric or a pattern you just have to make. This one began with my closet. Recently, I did a major closet purge. I took a good look at what I actually wear, what I kept reaching for, and—maybe more importantly—what was missing. Once the pieces I no longer loved or wore were gone, something became very clear: I want to be more intentional about what I sew next. Instead of sewing individual pieces that I love but don't necessarily wear together, I want to build a wardrobe where my handmade garments coordinate with the clothes I already own—and with the pieces I'm planning to sew next. For this month's Fabricista project, this beautiful lightweight shirting from Fabric Mart turned out to be a wonderful place to start. The Fabric That Started It All Fabric Mart provided this beautiful oatmeal and black heathered shirting , along with the matching thread for my project. One of the things I love most about this fabric is ...

The Perfect Plan for this Linen Blend! Until I Changed My Mind.

Hello Sewing Friends!  It’s Sharon from Sharon Sews with another Fabricista make.  When I saw this linen blend designer fabric on the Fabric Mart Fabrics website, I was intrigued.  After all, I, like many of you, love to find designer fabrics at an affordable price. It is a linen/nylon/rayon/Lycra blend, and I wondered what the designer had created with the fabric as I wasn’t familiar with that combination of fibers.  Surprisingly, I discovered a sleeveless, lined, mid-length vest in the same color with an almost identical fabric composition. Perfect! I’ve been wanting to sew a longer vest with matching pants, and that discovery confirmed this fabric would work beautifully for the look I had in mind.  The vest I’m wearing, from the June 2026 Burda Style magazine, it is not what I was originally going to make.  You see when I found the designer’s vest, I remembered seeing a Butterick pattern that was almost identical.  I ordered the pattern excited to...

Fall + Flannel = Shacket

If there is one piece that transitions easily between crisp fall mornings, mid-day warmth, and chilly autumn nights, it’s a shacket. Today, I’m excited to share my latest Fabric Mart make: the Ellie and Mac Patterns Connie Casual Shacket, sewn in a dreamy plaid flannel coating fabric . Here’s a glimpse at how it came together, along with a few construction tips for planning your own version! The Ellie and Mac Patterns Connie Casual Shacket pattern offers plenty of options needed to make the perfect transitional top layer for fall. With a relaxed body, oversized sleeves, three lengths, and a curved or straight hem option, you can make your dream shacket a reality.  For this sew, I selected a plaid flannel coating fabric with a soft blend of sage green and cream tones from the Fabric Mart website. Heavyweight flannel is ideal for a shacket because it provides structure and added warmth. As a bonus, this particular fabric is extra soft and snuggly, which I love. In addition to the fa...

Meeting Endless Summer Energy with a Maxi Dress

How are the temps still so hot?! I’m trying to make the best out of a blazing situation with a gorgeous swishy dress made in a splendid graphic print in an attempt to keep my cool when I am very much not. The heat persists, but so do I (while wearing sundresses)!  I really wanted a full length, all-fancy-design-details-included version of the new Chalk & Notch Noe Tank Dress since testing the pattern. This is View C. This version features a beautiful open back with a tie closure and the long gathered hem for maximum impact.  I chose the higher of two necklines. The pattern features full lining and I used the same fabric for both. I prefer to avoid any peeking-issues the easy way.  As I was scrolling through the challis options on the Fabric Mart site, this one stood out immediately, a beautiful kelly green with big abstract swipes of aqua. Simple, bold, (non-directional!), all of my favorite characteristics necessary for a showstopping dress. I wanted something very ...